
I had to take to the internet to look up the extended metaphor this article was making in regards to scaffolding problem based learning with interdisciplinary work. I had originally just looked up scaffolding and didn’t quite get it, so I sought the Glossary of Education Reform to get a better grasp. It’s basically a term that entails a sort of teaching that serves to teach hungry students how to fish. A professor teaches students the tools he/she needs to succeed in learning, and then steps back and let the students take an independent stance on their education. “Like physical scaffolding, the supportive strategies are incrementally removed when they are no longer necessary…”, and the teacher gradually lets the student fish entirely on his or her own. Diana Stentoft suggests that in order to do this, we break down typical disciplinary scaffolding by giving students more freedom over their equaling by using problem based learning in education to provoke interdiscplinarity work.
The article describes problem based learning as a, “potentially compelling pedagogical practice conducive for students learning across disciplines.” This kind of learning can be transdisciplinary learning, which believes the disciplines to be like puzzle pieces they need to put together on their own to create knowledge, or it can be interdisciplinary, where new knowledge is gained by understanding a connection between two disciplines. However, problem based learning serves to place interdisciplinary learning as a key component to the success of problem based learning. In my work as a beginning interdiscplinarian, I’ve found it extremely important to understand the differences between these definitions. Why do we need PBL?
In today’s constantly changing world, we must rely on developing new methods of study by merging pre-existing disciplines to prepare for our world to keep changing in the future. According to this article, “problems in society can rarely be contained within the boundaries of one single discipline,” therefore we need to rely on problem based learning anchored in a constructivist paradigm that inhibits Interdisciplinary work in solving society’s problems. I’ve found this to be true in my major. Typical marketing degrees don’t emphasize the social media skills, applied health knowledge, or graphic design skills I’ve built into my program, that most marketing manager jobs in the health world require of their candidates. Thi is an example of problem based learning because I’ve put my problem, getting a job when I graduate, “before the tools to solve it”…which in turn opens up the doors to “transgress disciplinary boundaries The article is careful to stress that the origin of problem based learning was actually originated in response to ever changing practices with medical students. It’s intentions were to “integrate subject areas, not to challenge epistemologies.”
PBL stresses that the teachers roles stressed that the teacher be the supervisor versus the facilitator. It’s the job of the teacher to and trust students in taking charge of a learning process that involves their “active engagement” with meaningful activities drawing on past experience. This part of problem based learning has even very crucial to my learning. I started my college career as a Finance major, and found that many the courses I was involved in were not meaningful to me. The outcome? I poorly engaged. I think part of this was because I was struggling to make connect the material I was learning, and partially because my classes were not an outcome of my work. They were an outcome of the template for my major I had to follow. Problem based learning is very student driven, and interdisciplinary work using PBL has made me feel like I have the reins on my education again.
However, article discusses a setback in PBL. Problem based learning curricula the problem really only “serves as a trigger [to fix the problem] and it and it establishes the purpose. The problem here is that “less attention is paid to competencies. We need to rely of the scaffolding of Interdisciplinary work to define epistemological, theoretical, and methodological problem to succeed. By using problem based learning to scaffold interdisciplinary work, we are creating clear guidelines.
One of students biggest struggles is dealing with the challenges of conflicting epistemologies regarding team work. This is where it’s the job of the teacher to step in to, ‘”guide students in the learning process,” and “facilitate new knowledge construction. The issue here is that teachers, like students, typically they’re not an expert in anyone field and are not used to this kind of methodology.
“A problem-based pedagogy which offers ways of organizing and addressing learning well suited to support interdisciplinarity.” We need to rely on the disciplines to be able to take theories and definitions from them, and mesh them with those of other disciplines to create new knowledge. This kind of work “increases meta cognitive skills,” and critical thinking skills. This kind of work doesn’t just happen. It takes effort from both the student and teacher.
To ensure that students don’t have issues don’t have epistemological issues working in teams with other students, Stentoft cites Biggs and Tang, 2009, “SOLO, or structure of observed learning outcomes stands is a “taxonomy where where students at the rational level develop establish structures of the academic elements they are supposed to engage with, relate arguments, give examples and make connections, and at the extended abstract level, derive abstract conceptions with which they apply to other, and broader, topics betting the narrow scope of a particular problem.” In my beginning work as an interdisciplinarian, I’ve understood just how crucial being able to fully articulate what it is that I’m studying, how I’m studying, and what Interdisciplinary work is. In my Intro to Interdisciplinary Studies course, the professor, Dr. Robin DeRosa, has done an incredible job at establishing a structure of learning outcomes. Our online textbook in filled with articles that provides Interdisciplinary Studies students all of the tools in which we’ll use to craft our program of study, and be able to talk about it, too. A minority in the university, being able to explain our course of study to outsiders who may be wary is very important.
Works Cited
Interdisciplinary Learning: Is Problem-Based Learning the Answer?” Active Learning in Higher Education, vol. 18, no. 1, 2017, pp. 51–61., doi:10.1177/146978741769351
“Scaffolding Definition.” The Glossary of Education Reform, 6 Apr. 2015, www.edglossary.org/scaffolding/.
Leave a Reply